Show Notes
Your variable speed pool pump is saving electricity, so why does the pool suddenly feel “different”? That’s the gap we tackle head-on, using real service-world examples that homeowners and even experienced pool pros run into right after a VS pump install. When you drop from a single speed pump at roughly 3450 RPM to lower speeds like 1800 to 2400 RPM, the pool’s surface velocity changes, skimming can feel weaker, and debris may not funnel to the skimmer the way you expect. Nothing is necessarily broken, but the behavior is different and it catches people off guard.
I walk through the practical tradeoffs: automatic pool cleaners that crawl at low speed, water features and spillways that look underpowered unless you schedule a higher RPM block, and why a “medium speed” around 2600 RPM is often the real-world setting that makes equipment function the way customers want. We also get into the part that triggers the most pushback, longer runtime. A VS pump may need far more hours to deliver comparable circulation, and I share an easy way to explain that to customers and what I do when they refuse to see a pump running late.
Then we go beyond performance into the stuff nobody puts on the box: sticker shock on VS pump pricing, expensive drive replacements, the added programming layer because the pump becomes its own timer, and how Department of Energy regulations have narrowed your choices. If you’re trying to balance energy savings, water quality, cleaner performance, and customer expectations, you’ll leave with a clear framework for setting RPM by pool size and scheduling speeds that actually match how the pool is used. Subscribe, share this with a pool owner or pool tech who’s fighting a “too long runtime” complaint, and leave a review with your biggest VS pump question.
We break down the real-world drawbacks people notice after switching from a single speed pump to a variable speed pool pump, even when the energy savings are undeniable. I share the issues that cause the most confusion, from weaker surface skimming to longer runtimes, plus how I program RPM based on cleaner needs and pool size.
• reduced surface velocity at low RPM leading to less skimmer pull
• why 1800 RPM can be a sweet spot for low speed
• automatic cleaner performance limits at low speed and typical RPM ranges that work
• water features and spillways looking weak unless you schedule higher speeds
• explaining longer VS runtimes to customers and when to stop fighting it
• why manufacturer “percentage savings” claims do not fit every pool
• programming and scheduling complexity since the pump becomes the timer
• higher price point, expensive drives, and why warranty support matters
• Department of Energy regulations reducing consumer choice
Are you a Pool Service Pro looking to take your business to the next level? Join the Pool Guy Coaching Program. Learn more at swimming poollearning.com. If you're looking for other podcasts, you can find those on my website, swimmingprolearning.com. And if you're interested in the coaching program, you can learn more at pullguycoaching.com.
Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors!
HASA REWARDS App
https://hasa.com/hasa-app
The Bottom Feeder. Save $100 with Code: DVB100
https://store.thebottomfeeder.com/
Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days:
https://getskimmer.com/poolguy
Get UPA Liability Insurance $64 a month! https://forms.gle/F9YoTWNQ8WnvT4QBA
Thanks for listening, and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:
Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.com
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPL
Podcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/
UPA General Liability Insurance Application: https://forms.gle/F9YoTWNQ8WnvT4QBA
Pool Guy Coaching Group
Join an exclusive network of Pool Service Technicians to access the industry’s leading commercial general liability insurance program. Protect your business.
Premium is $64 per month per member (additional $40 for employees and ICs)
$59 per month for Pool Guy coaching Members - join here! https://www.patreon.com/poolguycoaching
Limits are $1,000,000 in occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate - Per member limits
[ $1,000,000 per occurrence and $4,000,000 aggregate available for $75 per month ]
$50,000 in HazMat Coverage - clean up on-site or over-the-road
Acid Wash Coverage - Full Limits
Show Transcript
Welcome And What We’re Solving
SPEAKER_00 1:04
And welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to go over real life variable speed issues and cover some things that aren't really talked about when you're in the market for a variable speed pub. So let me go over some of these for you here in today's podcast. Are you a Pool Service Pro looking to take your business to the next level? Join the Pool Guy Coaching Program. Get expert advice, business tips, exclusive content, and get direct support from me. I'm a 35-year veteran in the industry. Whether you're starting out or scaling up, I've got the tools to help you succeed. Learn more at swimming poollearning.com.
Low RPM Skimming And Surface Flow
SPEAKER_00 1:40
If you're a pool service pro, you're probably pretty familiar with single speed pumps and how the pool looks and operates with a single speed pump. As a home motor, you may just have a single speed pump. And then you move to a variable speed pump. The first thing you're going to notice is that the surface velocity at the lower speeds is going to be quite different than your single speed pump.
In other words, the amount of debris that's going to be moved on the surface is much less. And you're going to notice that you're not going to have the same amount of debris going into the skimmer. There were a few people that tried to invent things that would go on the return jets to increase VS flow. I'm not sure if any of those ever came to market.
And what you're going to notice at 1800, 2100, 2400 RPMs is that the surface is not moving or the water is not moving on the surface nearly as well as that the 3450 with the RPMs of a single speed pump. I should go back and just kind of give you a little prepper on the RPMs or percentages of the speed. And that is that a single speed pump runs at 3450 RPMs revolutions per minute, which is a really fast speed, of course, and this is what causes the tremendous energy use of that particular pump. But the full speed, single speed pump did have did have its advantages in that it moved the water really well in the pool.
So you're going to get really rapid circulation at the full speed, a single speed pump. Now, with the variable speed pump, you can of course vary the speed, or some of them have percentages. And I'll just use RPMs because I'm more familiar with that than percentages. So a lot of VS pumps on a low speed, I would consider that about 1800 RPMs.
If you're comparing that to a dual speed pump, these were kind of like the first kind of variable speed pumps. They only had two speeds. The biggest problem with a dual speed pump is that low speed was like 1100 RPMs or so. It was really super low.
So it wasn't moving the water at all at the low speed in a dual speed pump. Fortunately for VS pumps, you can get a pretty good low speed. I prefer the low speed at 1800 RPMs. Some people put them at 1400.
I really feel like that much water is moving under 1800 RPMs. So that's like my sweet spot. And that's like under 200 watts anyway per hour at that speed. So it's one of those things where it's a preference, the low speed, of course.
And I like water to be moving in the pool. So I kind of like having the low speed at 1800 so that some water is moving in the pool.
Cleaners And Features Need Higher Speed
SPEAKER_00 4:26
So that's one of the things that you'll notice right away is that at the lower speeds, you'll notice this more with maybe a spa spillway or a water feature that's running on your pool at low speed. And of course, you're gonna know that this notice this with your automatic cleaner. At 1800 RPMs, no matter what automatic cleaner you have, it's not gonna really move in the pool too well. It'll just kind of crawl like a little turtle across the bottom of the pool.
If you have a bouncing type cleaner, it probably won't even bounce at all. So that's another kind of drawback of the variable speed pump is that in order to achieve the most energy efficiency, you're going to sacrifice some of the surface velocity, and you're also going to sacrifice automatic cleaner runtime, which technically isn't a terrible thing. So I'll go over I'll just go over the automatic cleaner issue. Now you can run most automatic cleaners at 2600 RPMs.
I've had to boost it up to 2800, sometimes 3000 RPMs on some pools, depending on the plumbing, the speed of the pump, other factors. You know, there's some hydraulic factors involved in the plumbing that cause you to have to have a little bit more speed with certain cleaners. But in most cases, most cleaners that I find I find will run off of 2600 RPMs, which I consider a medium speed. So yes, you're probably burning 400 watts per hour, more energy is being spent.
But the good thing is that you really don't need the automatic suction cleaner in most cases of running your pool more than six hours a day. You know, in the old days with the single speed pump, you would run the pump 12 hours or 10 hours a day, and an automatic cleaner would be running continuously during that time, which would really wear out the cleaner faster than if it was running with a variable speed pump, in my opinion, less time. So there is a side benefit of the automatic cleaner running less, and that is it doesn't wear out as quickly. The drawback is you may not get a fully clean pool within one cycle.
In the old days, you could probably bet that each day the automatic cleaner ran, the pool would be pretty spotless. So you may get 80% cleanliness on a VS pump running at 2600 RPMs, because that's not the speed you're gonna be running it at to save energy the longest. You're gonna run it at the lower speed to save energy and not the medium or high speed. So that is a drawback.
You're gonna see with the automatic cleaner, water features, things like that aren't gonna be very robust at the low speeds, and you're gonna have to run a medium and sometimes a high speed, if you like your water features to be on during the afternoon, you're gonna have to run it at a higher speed for that to work.
Longer Runtime And Customer Confusion
SPEAKER_00 7:13
Now there's no doubt that a variable speed pump saves electricity and saves on your energy bill, and it saves tremendously in some cases if you set it up correctly. So I'm not gonna argue energy savings here at all because the VS pump wins by a long shot over a single speed pump. I will say this though, that one problem you're gonna run up against if you do pool service and you just recently switch over the VS pump on your customer is that you're gonna get a lot of pushback on the longer runtime necessary for a VS pump. So that's not technically a drawback, that's just kind of how they operate.
You need a longer runtime for the VS pump to be effective or to circulate the pool as effectively as a single speed pump. For example, a single speed pump, you can run it 10 hours a day, it would get you know two or three cycles of water through, no problem. With a VS pump, if you have it at 1800 RPMs and you're running that at 12 hours a day, and then eight hours at 2600 RPMs, that's 20 hours of runtime, so double the runtime for about the same amount of circulation. A lot of customers can't comprehend this, they can't get their head around it.
They they normally will say, My pump normally comes on 7 in the morning and turns off at 5 p.m. And this pump is running until 10 p.m. at night, I don't I think there's a problem here. I need you to reset the pump and fix the long runtime, and then you have to go through a pretty big explanation in some cases of why that VS pump is running a lot longer for the same amount of circulation for the standard speed pump.
And I kind of use the freeway analogy. If you had a car and you're driving at 75 miles an hour and you're going from you know, Los Angeles to Las Vegas, you're gonna get there a lot faster. Then if you're driving a car at 45 miles an hour, the same distance, and they kind of it kind of clicks right away that the pump's running at a lower speed, therefore it needs to run longer. Now, sometimes this is the battle you can't win, and I've run into situations where the customer just doesn't want the pump running more than 10 hours a day because they are used to their pump running from 7 to 5.
So what I do is I just set a 2800 RPM speed, sometimes 3100, and just run it for that time period and don't battle the customer. There are certain pools, of course, where they're larger, you know, 25,000 gallons, and you can't run the normal 14, 1800 RPM and a 2600 RPM speed, even for 20 hours or 22 hours to get proper circulation. So you have to always account for the pool size as well. These numbers that the manufacturer gives you for energy savings, I think 80% or 90% energy savings, is based on a smaller body of water, with the pump running basically at 1800 RPMs for the whole period of time, but not any kind of medium speed or high speed.
So those numbers aren't necessarily accurate, although you do save a lot of energy. I wouldn't really go off with those numbers because they're definitely not accurate based on pool sizes and variations and how much flow you want in the pool and automatic cleaners, things like that. So in real in reality, you really want to set the speed and RPM based on the pool size. For a 15,000
Matching RPM To Pool Size
SPEAKER_00 10:47
gallon pool, easily can get away with 1800 RPMs and 2600 RPMs for different time periods for low and medium. For a 25,000 gallon pool, you're probably gonna have to run it at 3100, 3200 RPMs most of the time, with maybe a low speed of 2400 RPMs, because you really need to circulate that water for water quality. Now, in reality, you could just run it at the full 3450 rpms if you wanted to and just make it a single speed pump. That's really not gonna save you any energy, but it's gonna create the same flow and dynamics you had with your single speed pump. And there's no way that I'm saying here that a single speed pump is better than a variable speed pump. Hands down the VS pump is better, it's more versatile because of the ability to change the speeds, of course. But because it's running at lower speeds longer, it's going to last a lot longer than a single speed pump, in my opinion. In most cases, if you get a good VS pump, you know, Pentair, Jandy, Hayward, it's gonna last two or three times longer than a single speed pump of the same kind of category. Now, another drawback of the VS Pump, after saying that, is the price point. I don't
The Real Sticker Shock On VS
SPEAKER_00 12:00
know exactly, you know, what happened during COVID. I I kind of figured that there was there was a of course a run on pool builds, and so equipment was getting scarce, but the price increase across the board with chemicals, with equipment, I don't think it's justifiable in any kind of form that I can think of. I wouldn't say it's price gouging, but since the Department of Energy kind of mandated VS pumps and there was a shortage during that time and there was a decrease in Texas too, all these things kind of were a perfect storm, the price of these things is pretty pretty high, in my opinion, for what you're getting. If you're in the industry and you could you want to replace a drive, let's say on a Pentran teleflow pump, just the drive itself is like 900 bucks.
I mean, it's crazy the price of these things. And if you price out the in individual components, I mean brushless, motor, I'm sure wholesale is like I mean to get it made is like probably 100 bucks. And then the VS board and inverter, they probably buy thousands of these at the same time, so probably like 80 bucks. And then LED keypad, I mean LCD keypad, it can't be more than 10 bucks, you know, or 20 bucks.
And then the plastic and hydraulic seals and all the other things that go with it, maybe 300 bucks. So there is, in my opinion, of course, they have to get it over here from overseas and assemble it and put the weight end on, you know, all these things cost money, labor. But in the end, I don't know if the price is justifiable. It's just the fact that the big three control the market, and you can of course buy a variable speed pump on Amazon for like 400 bucks.
And it may not last you more than a couple years, but you know, if the components are that low, they can sell a pump for like three or four hundred dollars. I think I saw one at Home Depot the other day. It was like $300 for a VS pump sitting on the shelf. So that's even with the markup from Home Depot, you know.
So the components can't be that much money. But I'm going on a tangent here, and needless to say, the price of the VS pump is one of the biggest drawbacks that face the consumer in Pool Pro selling these things is you know, they're really expensive. And the fact that, you know, the the price is something that's non-negotiable, basically, unless you get a cheap pump on Amazon, you have to kind of buy this pump. And a lot of the kind of built-in savings, like the manufacturer mentions, you're gonna save electricity costs or energy costs, and you're gonna save wear and tear, it's gonna last a lot longer.
Those are true. You're gonna get some money back on the other end, but really it's not justifiable as far as paying $1,800 for a pump and getting all this money back over the course of three years. When if you paid $1,000 for it, you would even get more money back. So logically, it's it's a good sales and marketing pitch, but in my mind, not extremely justifiable.
A couple of quirks of the VS pump is of course that a lot of them have start, stop, on off,
Programming Mistakes And Tech Friction
SPEAKER_00 15:10
so you can actually leave this thing off all week long on accident if you're not careful if you have a standalone VS pump. So those are some things to be aware of. It's not like a single speed pump attached to an intermatic timer where you can kind of see the time that it's running. A lot of the VS pumps now need to be programmed and sometimes programmed from the controller itself on the back. So there's a layer of tech added to that that's somewhat confusing to maybe non-tech savvy homeowners or non-tech savvy pool pros. Basically, the VS pump acts as its own timer, so there's another layer there with the scheduling in the pump, scheduling with the automatic panel. You don't really rely on a timer anymore because the pump itself is the timer. So, again, that's another layer of technology that you have to learn if you're a homeowner. And a lot of older homeowners don't really want to learn that. I remember when these first came out, one of these was installed, and his homeowner was like 80 years old, and he was like calling all the time about like how do I turn on my spa, how do I do this and that. It was pretty much a nightmare for him to have a VS Pump, and it was of course a Pentan Teleflow second generation, which is even harder to operate. It's way complicated, and it's one of those things where no one talks about that, but it is a layer that you have to be aware of, the complication of having that as a timer, and then there's always the you know problem of someone not knowing how to use it and turning it off and leaving it off all week. So those are definitely built-in drawbacks. And I think the last drawback is that you really have no choice now but to go with a variable speed pump.
Mandates Warranties And Practical Choices
SPEAKER_00 16:52
Yes, I understand the savings and I understand all the good qualities of a ES pump, and I would not recommend a single speed pump to anyone personally because the variable speed pump is much better, regardless of kind of these minor drawbacks I'm mentioning here. But the fact you have no choice, I think, is the biggest drawback. With the Department of Energy's regulations, you can't put in a one horsepower, 1.5, sometimes a one horsepower, but a 1.5 or 2 horsepower pump any longer. And this does limit the consumer and pool pro and cause kind of this inflation and the price of VS pumps since there's really no choice but to get one.
It's if the government mandated electric vehicles one day, like you know, in two years from now, everyone has to have an electric car. Can imagine the price increase of these cars when there's a mandate like that in place. So that doesn't help, of course, and I'm one of those proponents that VS pumps save energy, they're a great product, but I'm also a proponent of having some choices out there as well. And you do have choices between brands, but you know, the warranty of the Pentair Heywood and Fluidra Jandy pumps far outweigh getting a cheap knockoff pump on Amazon where you probably have zero tech support, zero kind of if once it's installed, you're stuck with it if it dies after a month.
So it's one of those things where you're paying for a warranty as well. The price, of course, does include some built-in warranty. And I would say that that's one of the good things about the big manufacturers that they do they do stand behind their pumps, they're made really well, and if they do have a failure, like Hayward had a few years ago, they had a drive failure problem across the board. They replaced a lot of these, extended the warranty, so they do stand behind their products, and that is a good thing when you're buying from a major manufacturer.
If you're looking for other podcasts, you can find those on my website, swimmingprolearning.com. On the banner, click on the podcast icon. There'll be over
Where To Get More Help
SPEAKER_00 18:51
2,000 podcasts for you there. And if you're interested in the coaching program, you can learn more at pullguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a rest of your week. God bless.
Listen On
Also In Season 10
-
What Pool Service Pros Should Actually Worry About
Most pool service stress comes from imagining worst case scenarios that either n -
Most Pool Leaks Come From One Small Part
That puddle by the equipment pad can send you down a rabbit hole fast and someti -
Finish Your Pool Route Faster
Your pool service day can feel “busy” while still bleeding time in the worst pla -
Some Real Pool Business Tips
Four weeks off a year sounds impossible when you run a weekly pool route, but it
Chapters
- 0:00 Welcome And What We’re Solving
- 1:40 Low RPM Skimming And Surface Flow
- 4:26 Cleaners And Features Need Higher Speed
- 7:13 Longer Runtime And Customer Confusion
- 10:46 Matching RPM To Pool Size
- 12:00 The Real Sticker Shock On VS
- 15:09 Programming Mistakes And Tech Friction
- 16:51 Mandates Warranties And Practical Choices
- 18:51 Where To Get More Help
Transcript
Welcome And What We’re Solving SPEAKER_00 1:04 And welcome to the Pool Guy Podcast Show. In this episode, I'm going to go over real life variable speed issues and cover some things that aren't really talked about when you're in the market for a variable speed pub. So let me go over some of these for you here in today's podcast. Are you a Pool Service Pro looking to take your business to the next level?
Join the Pool Guy Coaching Program. Get expert advice, business tips, exclusive content, and get direct support from me. I'm a 35-year veteran in the industry. Whether you're starting out or scaling up, I've got the tools to help you succeed.
Learn more at swimming poollearning.com. Low RPM Skimming And Surface Flow SPEAKER_00 1:40 If you're a pool service pro, you're probably pretty familiar with single speed pumps and how the pool looks and operates with a single speed pump. As a home motor, you may just have a single speed pump. And then you move to a variable speed pump.
The first thing you're going to notice is that the surface velocity at the lower speeds is going to be quite different than your single speed pump. In other words, the amount of debris that's going to be moved on the surface is much less. And you're going to notice that you're not going to have the same amount of debris going into the skimmer. There were a few people that tried to invent things that would go on the return jets to increase VS flow.
I'm not sure if any of those ever came to market. And what you're going to notice at 1800, 2100, 2400 RPMs is that the surface is not moving or the water is not moving on the surface nearly as well as that the 3450 with the RPMs of a single speed pump. I should go back and just kind of give you a little prepper on the RPMs or percentages of the speed. And that is that a single speed pump runs at 3450 RPMs revolutions per minute, which is a really fast speed, of course, and this is what causes the tremendous energy use of that particular pump.
But the full speed, single speed pump did have did have its advantages in that it moved the water really well in the pool. So you're going to get really rapid circulation at the full speed, a single speed pump. Now, with the variable speed pump, you can of course vary the speed, or some of them have percentages. And I'll just use RPMs because I'm more familiar with that than percentages.
So a lot of VS pumps on a low speed, I would consider that about 1800 RPMs. If you're comparing that to a dual speed pump, these were kind of like the first kind of variable speed pumps. They only had two speeds. The biggest problem with a dual speed pump is that low speed was like 1100 RPMs or so.
It was really super low. So it wasn't moving the water at all at the low speed in a dual speed pump. Fortunately for VS pumps, you can get a pretty good low speed. I prefer the low speed at 1800 RPMs.
Some people put them at 1400. I really feel like that much water is moving under 1800 RPMs. So that's like my sweet spot. And that's like under 200 watts anyway per hour at that speed.
So it's one of those things where it's a preference, the low speed, of course. And I like water to be moving in the pool. So I kind of like having the low speed at 1800 so that some water is moving in the pool. Cleaners And Features Need Higher Speed SPEAKER_00 4:26 So that's one of the things that you'll notice right away is that at the lower speeds, you'll notice this more with maybe a spa spillway or a water feature that's running on your pool at low speed.
And of course, you're gonna know that this notice this with your automatic cleaner. At 1800 RPMs, no matter what automatic cleaner you have, it's not gonna really move in the pool too well. It'll just kind of crawl like a little turtle across the bottom of the pool. If you have a bouncing type cleaner, it probably won't even bounce at all.
So that's another kind of drawback of the variable speed pump is that in order to achieve the most energy efficiency, you're going to sacrifice some of the surface velocity, and you're also going to sacrifice automatic cleaner runtime, which technically isn't a terrible thing. So I'll go over I'll just go over the automatic cleaner issue. Now you can run most automatic cleaners at 2600 RPMs. I've had to boost it up to 2800, sometimes 3000 RPMs on some pools, depending on the plumbing, the speed of the pump, other factors.
You know, there's some hydraulic factors involved in the plumbing that cause you to have to have a little bit more speed with certain cleaners. But in most cases, most cleaners that I find I find will run off of 2600 RPMs, which I consider a medium speed. So yes, you're probably burning 400 watts per hour, more energy is being spent. But the good thing is that you really don't need the automatic suction cleaner in most cases of running your pool more than six hours a day.
You know, in the old days with the single speed pump, you would run the pump 12 hours or 10 hours a day, and an automatic cleaner would be running continuously during that time, which would really wear out the cleaner faster than if it was running with a variable speed pump, in my opinion, less time. So there is a side benefit of the automatic cleaner running less, and that is it doesn't wear out as quickly. The drawback is you may not get a fully clean pool within one cycle. In the old days, you could probably bet that each day the automatic cleaner ran, the pool would be pretty spotless.
So you may get 80% cleanliness on a VS pump running at 2600 RPMs, because that's not the speed you're gonna be running it at to save energy the longest. You're gonna run it at the lower speed to save energy and not the medium or high speed. So that is a drawback. You're gonna see with the automatic cleaner, water features, things like that aren't gonna be very robust at the low speeds, and you're gonna have to run a medium and sometimes a high speed, if you like your water features to be on during the afternoon, you're gonna have to run it at a higher speed for that to work.
Longer Runtime And Customer Confusion SPEAKER_00 7:13 Now there's no doubt that a variable speed pump saves electricity and saves on your energy bill, and it saves tremendously in some cases if you set it up correctly. So I'm not gonna argue energy savings here at all because the VS pump wins by a long shot over a single speed pump. I will say this though, that one problem you're gonna run up against if you do pool service and you just recently switch over the VS pump on your customer is that you're gonna get a lot of pushback on the longer runtime necessary for a VS pump. So that's not technically a drawback, that's just kind of how they operate.
You need a longer runtime for the VS pump to be effective or to circulate the pool as effectively as a single speed pump. For example, a single speed pump, you can run it 10 hours a day, it would get you know two or three cycles of water through, no problem. With a VS pump, if you have it at 1800 RPMs and you're running that at 12 hours a day, and then eight hours at 2600 RPMs, that's 20 hours of runtime, so double the runtime for about the same amount of circulation. A lot of customers can't comprehend this, they can't get their head around it.
They they normally will say, My pump normally comes on 7 in the morning and turns off at 5 p.m. And this pump is running until 10 p.m. at night, I don't I think there's a problem here. I need you to reset the pump and fix the long runtime, and then you have to go through a pretty big explanation in some cases of why that VS pump is running a lot longer for the same amount of circulation for the standard speed pump.
And I kind of use the freeway analogy. If you had a car and you're driving at 75 miles an hour and you're going from you know, Los Angeles to Las Vegas, you're gonna get there a lot faster. Then if you're driving a car at 45 miles an hour, the same distance, and they kind of it kind of clicks right away that the pump's running at a lower speed, therefore it needs to run longer. Now, sometimes this is the battle you can't win, and I've run into situations where the customer just doesn't want the pump running more than 10 hours a day because they are used to their pump running from 7 to 5.
So what I do is I just set a 2800 RPM speed, sometimes 3100, and just run it for that time period and don't battle the customer. There are certain pools, of course, where they're larger, you know, 25,000 gallons, and you can't run the normal 14, 1800 RPM and a 2600 RPM speed, even for 20 hours or 22 hours to get proper circulation. So you have to always account for the pool size as well. These numbers that the manufacturer gives you for energy savings, I think 80% or 90% energy savings, is based on a smaller body of water, with the pump running basically at 1800 RPMs for the whole period of time, but not any kind of medium speed or high speed.
So those numbers aren't necessarily accurate, although you do save a lot of energy. I wouldn't really go off with those numbers because they're definitely not accurate based on pool sizes and variations and how much flow you want in the pool and automatic cleaners, things like that. So in real in reality, you really want to set the speed and RPM based on the pool size. For a 15,000 Matching RPM To Pool Size SPEAKER_00 10:47 gallon pool, easily can get away with 1800 RPMs and 2600 RPMs for different time periods for low and medium.
For a 25,000 gallon pool, you're probably gonna have to run it at 3100, 3200 RPMs most of the time, with maybe a low speed of 2400 RPMs, because you really need to circulate that water for water quality. Now, in reality, you could just run it at the full 3450 rpms if you wanted to and just make it a single speed pump. That's really not gonna save you any energy, but it's gonna create the same flow and dynamics you had with your single speed pump. And there's no way that I'm saying here that a single speed pump is better than a variable speed pump.
Hands down the VS pump is better, it's more versatile because of the ability to change the speeds, of course. But because it's running at lower speeds longer, it's going to last a lot longer than a single speed pump, in my opinion. In most cases, if you get a good VS pump, you know, Pentair, Jandy, Hayward, it's gonna last two or three times longer than a single speed pump of the same kind of category. Now, another drawback of the VS Pump, after saying that, is the price point.
I don't The Real Sticker Shock On VS SPEAKER_00 12:00 know exactly, you know, what happened during COVID. I I kind of figured that there was there was a of course a run on pool builds, and so equipment was getting scarce, but the price increase across the board with chemicals, with equipment, I don't think it's justifiable in any kind of form that I can think of. I wouldn't say it's price gouging, but since the Department of Energy kind of mandated VS pumps and there was a shortage during that time and there was a decrease in Texas too, all these things kind of were a perfect storm, the price of these things is pretty pretty high, in my opinion, for what you're getting. If you're in the industry and you could you want to replace a drive, let's say on a Pentran teleflow pump, just the drive itself is like 900 bucks.
I mean, it's crazy the price of these things. And if you price out the in individual components, I mean brushless, motor, I'm sure wholesale is like I mean to get it made is like probably 100 bucks. And then the VS board and inverter, they probably buy thousands of these at the same time, so probably like 80 bucks. And then LED keypad, I mean LCD keypad, it can't be more than 10 bucks, you know, or 20 bucks.
And then the plastic and hydraulic seals and all the other things that go with it, maybe 300 bucks. So there is, in my opinion, of course, they have to get it over here from overseas and assemble it and put the weight end on, you know, all these things cost money, labor. But in the end, I don't know if the price is justifiable. It's just the fact that the big three control the market, and you can of course buy a variable speed pump on Amazon for like 400 bucks.
And it may not last you more than a couple years, but you know, if the components are that low, they can sell a pump for like three or four hundred dollars. I think I saw one at Home Depot the other day. It was like $300 for a VS pump sitting on the shelf. So that's even with the markup from Home Depot, you know.
So the components can't be that much money. But I'm going on a tangent here, and needless to say, the price of the VS pump is one of the biggest drawbacks that face the consumer in Pool Pro selling these things is you know, they're really expensive. And the fact that, you know, the the price is something that's non-negotiable, basically, unless you get a cheap pump on Amazon, you have to kind of buy this pump. And a lot of the kind of built-in savings, like the manufacturer mentions, you're gonna save electricity costs or energy costs, and you're gonna save wear and tear, it's gonna last a lot longer.
Those are true. You're gonna get some money back on the other end, but really it's not justifiable as far as paying $1,800 for a pump and getting all this money back over the course of three years. When if you paid $1,000 for it, you would even get more money back. So logically, it's it's a good sales and marketing pitch, but in my mind, not extremely justifiable.
A couple of quirks of the VS pump is of course that a lot of them have start, stop, on off, Programming Mistakes And Tech Friction SPEAKER_00 15:10 so you can actually leave this thing off all week long on accident if you're not careful if you have a standalone VS pump. So those are some things to be aware of. It's not like a single speed pump attached to an intermatic timer where you can kind of see the time that it's running. A lot of the VS pumps now need to be programmed and sometimes programmed from the controller itself on the back.
So there's a layer of tech added to that that's somewhat confusing to maybe non-tech savvy homeowners or non-tech savvy pool pros. Basically, the VS pump acts as its own timer, so there's another layer there with the scheduling in the pump, scheduling with the automatic panel. You don't really rely on a timer anymore because the pump itself is the timer. So, again, that's another layer of technology that you have to learn if you're a homeowner.
And a lot of older homeowners don't really want to learn that. I remember when these first came out, one of these was installed, and his homeowner was like 80 years old, and he was like calling all the time about like how do I turn on my spa, how do I do this and that. It was pretty much a nightmare for him to have a VS Pump, and it was of course a Pentan Teleflow second generation, which is even harder to operate. It's way complicated, and it's one of those things where no one talks about that, but it is a layer that you have to be aware of, the complication of having that as a timer, and then there's always the you know problem of someone not knowing how to use it and turning it off and leaving it off all week.
So those are definitely built-in drawbacks. And I think the last drawback is that you really have no choice now but to go with a variable speed pump. Mandates Warranties And Practical Choices SPEAKER_00 16:52 Yes, I understand the savings and I understand all the good qualities of a ES pump, and I would not recommend a single speed pump to anyone personally because the variable speed pump is much better, regardless of kind of these minor drawbacks I'm mentioning here. But the fact you have no choice, I think, is the biggest drawback.
With the Department of Energy's regulations, you can't put in a one horsepower, 1.5, sometimes a one horsepower, but a 1.5 or 2 horsepower pump any longer. And this does limit the consumer and pool pro and cause kind of this inflation and the price of VS pumps since there's really no choice but to get one. It's if the government mandated electric vehicles one day, like you know, in two years from now, everyone has to have an electric car. Can imagine the price increase of these cars when there's a mandate like that in place.
So that doesn't help, of course, and I'm one of those proponents that VS pumps save energy, they're a great product, but I'm also a proponent of having some choices out there as well. And you do have choices between brands, but you know, the warranty of the Pentair Heywood and Fluidra Jandy pumps far outweigh getting a cheap knockoff pump on Amazon where you probably have zero tech support, zero kind of if once it's installed, you're stuck with it if it dies after a month. So it's one of those things where you're paying for a warranty as well. The price, of course, does include some built-in warranty.
And I would say that that's one of the good things about the big manufacturers that they do they do stand behind their pumps, they're made really well, and if they do have a failure, like Hayward had a few years ago, they had a drive failure problem across the board. They replaced a lot of these, extended the warranty, so they do stand behind their products, and that is a good thing when you're buying from a major manufacturer. If you're looking for other podcasts, you can find those on my website, swimmingprolearning.com. On the banner, click on the podcast icon.
There'll be over Where To Get More Help SPEAKER_00 18:51 2,000 podcasts for you there. And if you're interested in the coaching program, you can learn more at pullguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a rest of your week.
God bless.