A $600 variable speed pump on Amazon can make any pool pro feel like they’re losing a pricing argument before they even open their mouth. But the real question is not what the pump costs. It’s what happens when it fails, who pays for the diagnosis, and whether anyone shows up to make it right. We dig into how cheap pool equipment, overseas manufacturing, and online marketplaces are reshaping customer expectations and putting pressure on distributors and service companies. Harold Evans joins ...

Show Notes

A $600 variable speed pump on Amazon can make any pool pro feel like they’re losing a pricing argument before they even open their mouth. But the real question is not what the pump costs. It’s what happens when it fails, who pays for the diagnosis, and whether anyone shows up to make it right. We dig into how cheap pool equipment, overseas manufacturing, and online marketplaces are reshaping customer expectations and putting pressure on distributors and service companies.

Harold Evans joins me to talk about consolidation and pool service roll-ups, and why the “second bite” promise often doesn’t match reality. We get specific about what makes the pool industry harder to roll up than businesses like pest control: fewer stops per day, higher cost of goods sold, and thinner margins once you stack venture capital profit demands, corporate overhead, and debt service on top of labor. That mismatch creates pressure that can break culture, weaken service quality, and force companies into tough exits.

We also bring it back to what actually wins long-term: investing in technicians, training, and the customer experience. If buyers can get parts anywhere, your advantage is the outcome you deliver, the risk you take off the homeowner’s plate, and the trust you earn over years of consistent work. If you found this useful, subscribe, share it with a pool pro, and leave a review so more people in the pool industry can find the show.

We look ten years ahead and ask what happens to pool service when consolidation grows and cheap online equipment resets customer expectations. Harold Evans explains why roll-ups struggle in the pool industry and why the winning move is investing in people and outcomes, not chasing commodity pricing.

• roll-ups and consolidation challenges driven by culture and process conflicts
• why “second bite” payouts often fail to materialize for sellers
• pool industry economics compared with pest control economics
• venture capital expectations, debt service, and margin pressure in service models
• shifting from selling products to selling trust, talent, and consistent outcomes
• repair vs replace thinking to reduce risk and improve long-term reliability
• Amazon pricing and generic variable speed pumps changing the sales conversation
• warranty support, training, and service infrastructure as hidden costs in OEM pricing
• big box retailers and online marketplaces squeezing traditional distribution

Learn more at Swimmypoollearning.com.
If you're looking for other podcasts, you can find those by going to my website, so you learning.com on the banner, click on the podcast icon.
And if you're interested in the coaching program, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com.

Send us Fan Mail

Support the Pool Guy Podcast Show Sponsors! 

HASA  REWARDS App
https://hasa.com/hasa-app

The Bottom Feeder. Save $100 with Code: DVB100
https://store.thebottomfeeder.com/

Try Skimmer FREE for 30 days:
https://getskimmer.com/poolguy 

Get UPA Liability Insurance $64 a month! https://forms.gle/F9YoTWNQ8WnvT4QBA





Support the show

Thanks for listening, and I hope you find the Podcast helpful! For other free resources to further help you:
Visit my Website: https://www.swimmingpoollearning.com
Watch on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@SPL
Podcast Site: https://the-pool-guy-podcast-show.onpodium.com/

UPA General Liability Insurance Application: https://forms.gle/F9YoTWNQ8WnvT4QBA

Pool Guy Coaching Group

Join an exclusive network of Pool Service Technicians to access the industry’s leading commercial general liability insurance program. Protect your business.

Premium is $64 per month per member (additional $40 for employees and ICs)

$59 per month for Pool Guy coaching Members - join here! https://www.patreon.com/poolguycoaching

Limits are $1,000,000 in occurrence and $2,000,000 in the aggregate - Per member limits

     [ $1,000,000 per occurrence and $4,000,000 aggregate available for $75 per month ]

$50,000 in HazMat Coverage - clean up on-site or over-the-road

Acid Wash Coverage - Full Limits

Show Transcript

Welcome And Industry Forecast

SPEAKER_00 1:04

Hey, welcome to the Pool Green Podcast Show. Today Harold Evans is joining me and he's gonna talk a little bit about big companies. He's gonna use the term roll-up, which is basically those big companies that are buying all the small companies or fairly small companies and just making them into one giant pool

Coaching Program Invite

SPEAKER_00 1:22

company for the area and how that's going and what the future of that holds for the industry. And we'll touch a little bit on distribution as well and some things regarding what distributors are struggling with or facing in the market today. Are you a pool service pro looking to take your business to the next level? Join the pool guy coaching program. Get expert

Cheap Online Equipment Pressure

SPEAKER_00 1:42

advice, business tips, exclusive content, and get direct support. From me, I'm a 35-year veteran in the industry. Whether you're starting out or scaling up, I've got the tools to help you succeed. Learn more at Swimmypoollearning.com. Yeah, so let's let's take a look at the future of the pool industry. Ten years from now, how do you think things will look? Now, I'll just preface with this here. One thing I noticed on Amazon lately is that there's a lot of generic variable speed pumps out there, a lot of pool equipment that's coming on the market on Amazon. Of course, the generic pool parts have always been up there. Distributors can't compete with the generic prices because they're under contract with you know Pinter, Hayward, and Jandy to buy OEM products. So that's also changing the landscape. The fact that there's so much stuff coming from overseas and kind of populating the internet. And when you're a pool pro and you're like trying to sell them a VS Pump for $1800 and they see it on Amazon for $600, really hard argument to fight with the customer on that aspect. But you mentioned the consolidation, big companies coming in, making pool companies like Terminix, you know, they're just with hundreds of employees and giant territories. What do you think is going to happen in the 10 years? This distribution, how's that going to be affected? The backyard pool service with all these acquisitions and these giant companies starting.

Consolidation And The Second Bite

SPEAKER_00 3:07

I mean, it's one of those things where in 10 years from now, the landscape probably will be a lot different than it is now.

SPEAKER_01 3:16

I don't think that the roll-ups, the consolidation of service is going to be successful over time. I believe that most of the when you look at a model of a small, you know, like you, David, a one polar or even maybe, you know, bipolar, if you will, you look at the culture, you look at the assimilation factor, you know, you run your business your way, I run my business my way, and then we come together, and then we got to figure out how to agree on how to do it. That's the roll-up challenge. And then to compound that, we've been uh reluctant to raise rates consistently as an industry.

And as a result, a lot of people are undervalued in their product. And so when they go to sell their company, their notion of devaluation doesn't meet the financial reality. And so what ends up happening is they end up taking less money for their company, thinking that they're going to get what they call the second bite, which is when you roll these things up, they're going to be worth more in the aggregate than they are separate, which sounds good in theory. But in my opinion, I've yet to see second bites work successfully, other than the roll-up that happened with heritage and the distribution model.

But I have not seen anyone succeed at that. And so my prediction is that our industry is more complicated to roll up than others. And constantly what you hear is well, you know, we've done it in the pest business or whatever. And there's a very, very important distinction because I'm close to some of the people that run those things without being specific.

Where the variation and where the uh intersecting conflict comes from is in the pest business, for example, you can pay better because you make more frequent trips in a day. The time required to squirt around for quarterly service takes minutes and not hours. And so you can get way more trips out of the same truck and the same individual, and therefore can pay more because you're revenuing more. And most importantly, the cost of goods sold in the pest control business is substantially different than in the pool business.

So our cost of goods sold is, you know, I'm gonna argue north to 30%. Just cost of goods, forget about labor. In the pest control business, it's my understanding, it's closer to 4%. So there's not a fair measure to look at the two businesses in the same way.

And a lot of the people that came out of pest have expectations, and they also have expectations for repair, they're a complete fantasy. Some of those models I know are looking at three to five thousand dollars a year in ancillary repair business from

Why VC Math Breaks In Pools

SPEAKER_01 5:55

having a pool on service, which is silly. You know, if every one of our customers spent three to five thousand dollars on equipment every year, you know, we probably wouldn't be sitting here talking about it. We'd be spending the money somewhere, or you'd be buying more rent houses, David. So I don't think it's a sustainable model.

So you take a cultural conflict from the get-go, people that have operated businesses successfully by their measure, whatever that is, and it may be different than my measure, but when you get successful people in one room trying to agree on a process, it's it's it's not easy. And the cultural assimilation of those companies has been awkward across the board. I mean, every friend of mine that will remain nameless has told me that the expectation and the outcome were not there, that they were disappointed by the assimilation and then it didn't go the way they thought it would. And that they thought that while they didn't get what they should have gotten for the sale of their business, they were going to get it on the other side of it.

And I'm unaware of any of those conversions working, which they call the second bite, which is if you sell your company for less money with the anticipation that you get paid more when the whole thing sells, that hasn't happened that I know of anyway. So there could be an I'm unaware of. But that's and the other thing to look at is, you know, I ran a business and still run a business without debt. And so you've got venture capital expectation of profit, you've got corporate expectation of profit, and then you got debt service.

Those are all burdens that I don't think there's an economy to support in our industry, and pay the VC, pay the bank, and pay the company. That's too many people trying to get too little, too little percentage. So they get under pressure, and a lot of those companies end up being forced by the banks to sell their companies because they continue to have a thirst for capital that the bank won't provide them anymore. So I think the roll-ups are going to be questionable.

And then, of course, those that initially, when the rollups came out, they were paying less money for construction companies and more for service. And I do know that the expectation in those models is that a service contract is worth more money than a cool construction business or a repair business. But I do think that the expectation for repair revenue is completely silly and unaccomplishable. And I'm I'm unaware of anybody that's consistently delivering that.

There probably could be people being on the table table telling you that they are, but uh I haven't seen it. If if it's happening, I'm unaware of it. So I do think that our model of purchasing is going to permanently change. And I think that I've always said that people hire the pool surgeon in Dallas because of the amazing employees that we have, not the products that we sell, and our ability to maneuver and control outcomes.

So if you don't figure out that you're not selling a commodity that's provided by anybody, but it's provided by the individuals that provide service in your business, then you're missing the mark. I can tell you for a fact, because I have 30-year employees, that I mean, my wife just went and had acupuncture done. And our acupuncturist has been a pool surgeon customer for 20 years. Knows Cecil, my lead repair technician, knows my son, knows our history.

And so, you know, what's the point? She wouldn't navigate her pool. She told my wife that. I wouldn't have a pool and I wouldn't navigate anybody else working on my pool but Cecil.

So that's where we need

Talent And Trust Beat Commodity

SPEAKER_01 10:07

to be looking at is investing in the talent and training that talent and making life uncomfortable, which I think COVID helped us with. COVID helped us stop commoditizing and focus on outcome. If our products aren't what people are looking at, it's did they come away with less friction and outcome they were looking for? You know, inherently pool repair people like to fix things. And sometimes it isn't time to fix, it's time to replace. Sometimes people replace because they don't know how to fix. But in most cases, we spend too much energy trying to fix things that need to be replaced, i.e., you know, do you put a burner tray in a 15-year-old heater? I would say absolutely no. That's also due to my customer base because of all the inherent risk of investing in a dilapidated has-been piece of equipment. The inclination of a lot of repair people is to try to fix everything. And I think that there's pressure to look away from that. Now, as for the what's going on in the in the in the

The Hidden Cost Of Warranty

SPEAKER_01 11:11

whole whole goods market, call it the big three and beyond, there's a lot of unfair assessments being made here, in my opinion. So we've all grown accustomed to having immediate service people out supporting the branded products, going on trips, all the compounding overheads that that center around the big three, if you will, providing relationships, support, and products. And then there was probably some reckless pricing that went on as availability became more difficult and haven't correct themselves. But it isn't fair to take a manufacturer from China that comes in here and was making products for a domestic manufacturer that was adding value by the way they supported the product, the way they trained, the way they had field service people supporting that business, and look at that and go, oh, well, that's less expensive.

Well, they don't have any warranty support. They don't have any trips you're taking. So the trap that kind of everyone's gonna have to look at is in order to compete, if that's where this is headed, then you better be making your own vacation plans and not going on the trip, right? You better figure out what happens when that product doesn't work and you think it's under warranty.

Who's gonna pay for that investigation? I remember the early days of that when I was sitting with Vance Gillette, God rest his soul, and we were talking about warranty, and I was performing warranty and they were providing me parts. And I said, listen, you've got to give me some labor dollars for this trouble, or I'm gonna quit supporting your product. I can't go out there and just because you give me parts, go fix your problem.

So that was the advent of them having reimbursement for some of the repair, which changed the industry. A lot of warranty work was being done at the expense of the installer with a part that was free, big deal. And that transition. So if you're gonna buy the foreign product that was produced overseas, you know, who's to say it's the same product that they were providing to the OEM manufacturer that you've grown accustomed to and have a relationship with?

And secondly, who's gonna help you if you're a pool builder and you're waiting for your final check and the pump doesn't come on, who's gonna come out and make sure it works? Who's gonna pay for that? So there's been an almost sloppy arrogance of expectation from the big three to support to a fall, including enabling bad behavior, that will change over time if this is where we're headed. If we're gonna go toward the price model, then you're gonna get what goes with the price model.

You can't go to, well, you can go to Costco and get new and Marcus' expectation of service, but that's not sustainable. If you want the service, then you're gonna pay more for it. If you want somebody to come out and make sure it's right and and hold your hand and teach you, that has opportunity costs. And it's not fair for people to show up at these trainings and then turn around and buy somebody else's product and then complain about price.

You know, you're you're harvesting something you're not paying for. So we've got to be responsible in that way and decide. From my perspective, I'm not gonna provide the knockoff products because uh it's important that I have that ability to make my customer happy by being able to send a bill to a manufacturer for a flaw in their product that that I don't get penalized for and that I can support that properly.

SPEAKER_00 14:34

And that's what I tell the customers is that you know, if you buy one of these pumps on Amazon for 600, maybe you get three years out of

Big Box Stores And Distributor Squeeze

SPEAKER_00 14:41

it, you know, and then by the time you buy you know a Hayward or Penta or Jandy pump, you'll get 10, 12 years out of the same VS pump. So you'll be putting four of these pumps in over the course of 12 years instead of one. And like you mentioned, the price that the manufacturer sells it for, there's built-in warranty, there's built-in cost that they have to factor into their pricing. So it's it's one of those things where a lot of people look at it.

Like when I get a water heater for one of my rentals, I always get one my plumber puts in from his supplier. It's like three times the price of the one at Home Depot, but it has a five-year automatic warranty right there with no questions asked, and then these things last a lot longer. So there is something to be said with educating the customer, which doesn't happen on Amazon, by the way, because they're just clicking on it, buying it. There's nothing in there about a warranty or who's gonna support it.

So I think the Pool Pro has to be proactive and say, you know, Mr. Jones, this pump costs this much money because of these factors that you don't see on Amazon. And I think, you know, as Home Depot starts carrying equipment, they have, I was just looking at it just now, they have 100, 260 filter items on Home Depot right now. And some of them are name brand products.

So a lot of the stores, like, you know, if Costco ever starts getting pool equipment, you know, it's gonna be a killer the way they price things with 10% markup, it's gonna just destroy the market. So as more of these stores get equipment, Walmart, Home Depot. I think the distributors may feel a pinch, even if people buy the, you know, the from the big three, they're still gonna have a lot more shopping options out there with the big box stores, you know, carrying equipment.

SPEAKER_01 16:25

Well, it gets back to exactly, David, to what I said earlier, and that is what are you focused on here? Are you gonna focus on the name brand that you're putting on a pool? Or are you gonna focus on the fact that life with Cecil is safer, it's better, you have a confidant.

SPEAKER_00 16:40

I mean, if you're looking for other podcasts, you can find those by going to my website, so you learning.com on the banner, click on the podcast

Final Links And Farewell

SPEAKER_00 16:47

icon. That'll take you to over 2,000 podcasts that are listened to. And if you're interested in the coaching program, you can learn more at poolguycoaching.com. Thanks for listening to this podcast. Have a great rest of your week and God bless.